Willis McCall served as the sheriff of Lake County, Florida, from 1944 to 1972, making him a significant figure in local law enforcement during a tumultuous period marked by racial tensions. Known for his aggressive and often violent tactics, McCall was a staunch defender of segregation and frequently employed harsh methods to maintain order, particularly against Black individuals. His approach reflected the systemic racism of the time, contributing to a legacy steeped in controversy.

One of the most infamous incidents of his career occurred in 1949 when Norma Padgett accused four Black men—Sam Shepherd, Walter Irvin, Charles Greenlee, and Erron Lawton—of raping her. McCall led a brutal manhunt for the suspects, inciting mob violence and encouraging community retribution. During the chaotic aftermath, Shepherd attempted to escape while being transported by McCall and was shot and killed by the sheriff, who claimed self-defense. This incident underscored McCall’s readiness to use violence and further damaged the lives of the accused men.

Despite the serious accusations and the backlash from civil rights advocates, McCall maintained strong support among local white residents, allowing him to win multiple elections throughout his tenure. Many viewed him as a protector of law and order, which helped him withstand criticism and controversies regarding his conduct. His long-standing position exemplified the entrenched racial attitudes of the era and the challenges faced by those seeking justice and equality.

McCall’s legacy is a complex one, serving as a reminder of the systemic racism embedded in the legal system and the ongoing struggle for civil rights in America. His actions and the environment he fostered highlighted the deep divisions in society, making him a controversial figure in the history of law enforcement in Florida.